Pony Island (2016)

- Developer
- Daniel Mullins Games
- Platforms
- Windows, macOS, Linux
- Genres
- Indie
- Rating
- 4.8 of 5, 18,043 player ratings
- Typical playtime
- about 3.8 hours
- Where to get it
- Steam
How it feels
A tense, self-aware puzzle game where you hack through a broken arcade machine while the Devil taunts you.
suspensefulpuzzlepsychological horroratmosphericdarkly humorousshortmetafictionalexperimental
What players say
A very brief meta puzzle game that leans on a single joke and ends before it wears thin. Players praise its clever puzzles and eerie atmosphere, but warn that the side-scroller gameplay can feel repetitive. A few note that the game lacks native controller support.
Trailer
Screenshots





More games like this
- The Witness (2016)
- Simple Game (2023)
- Fremdganger - The Cheating Demon (2023)
- Selma and the Wisp (2016)
- Awareness Rooms (2016)
- Bad Dream: Fever (2018)
- Sally Face - Episode One (2016)
- Father“s Island (2016)
More by Daniel Mullins Games
- Inscryption (2021)
- The Hex (2018)
- Dread X Collection 2 (2020)
This page is from Underplayed Gems, a catalog of older and overlooked games. Not quite it? Tell the Catbot what you feel like playing and it picks from the whole catalog, or browse by platform and genre.