Underplayed Gems

The Game Maker: A Carol Reed Mystery (2025)

The Game Maker: A Carol Reed Mystery cover
Developer
MDNA Games
Platforms
Windows
Genres
Adventure
Rating
4.4 of 5, 8 player ratings
Typical playtime
about 6.1 hours
Where to get it
Steam

How it feels

A slow-burn mystery adventure where you methodically interrogate odd characters and piece together clues to uncover a serial killer's motives.

mysteriousdeliberateinvestigativeunsettlingpuzzle-solvingstory-drivenmethodicaleccentric

What players say

Players praise the photo-realistic Swedish scenery and atmospheric music, but note the dungeon-crawler movement and harsh pixel-hunting (mitigated by a highlight key). It is a standalone entry in a long-running series, with minigames added for the first time. Some find clues too vague and the world lifeless due to few NPCs and minimal voice acting.

Screenshots

The Game Maker: A Carol Reed Mystery screenshot 1

More games like this

More by MDNA Games

This page is from Underplayed Gems, a catalog of older and overlooked games. Not quite it? Tell the Catbot what you feel like playing and it picks from the whole catalog, or browse by platform and genre.