Underplayed Gems

The Lies We Tell Ourselves (2025)

The Lies We Tell Ourselves cover
Developer
Poopsy
Platforms
Windows
Genres
Adventure, Indie
Rating
3.6 of 5, 123 player ratings
Typical playtime
about 4.0 hours
Where to get it
Steam

How it feels

A methodical, episodic first-person journey through a dark, story-rich world with deliberate puzzles and sparse horror that prioritizes atmosphere over jump scares.

psychologicalatmosphericintrospectivesubtle storytellingpuzzle-heavydarksurrealfirst-person

What players say

Players appreciate the graphics, music, and story but are split on the pacing. Many find the cutscenes unskippable and the walking speed too slow, and complain about save points that force restarting levels. Puzzles are considered rewarding by some, frustrating by others. It is the first chapter of a multi-chapter release.

Screenshots

The Lies We Tell Ourselves screenshot 1The Lies We Tell Ourselves screenshot 2The Lies We Tell Ourselves screenshot 3The Lies We Tell Ourselves screenshot 4The Lies We Tell Ourselves screenshot 5The Lies We Tell Ourselves screenshot 6

More games like this

This page is from Underplayed Gems, a catalog of older and overlooked games. Not quite it? Tell the Catbot what you feel like playing and it picks from the whole catalog, or browse by platform and genre.