Underplayed Gems

Game Pulse Payoff Pitch (2026)

Game Pulse Payoff Pitch cover
Developer
Fireside Experience
Publisher
Sideline Strategy Games
Platforms
Windows
Genres
Simulation, Sports, Strategy
Rating
3.1 of 5, 8 player ratings
Typical playtime
about 12 hours
Where to get it
Steam

How it feels

A methodical, decision-heavy baseball manager that asks you to weigh every pitch and lineup choice with calculated calm.

simulationstrategicmethodicaltensemanagerialanalyticaltacticalrealistic

What players say

Players are split: some enjoy the dice-and-card baseball engine and active developer support, while others say it was released unfinished with lineup order bugs and missing updates, making long-term play unreliable.

More games like this

This page is from Underplayed Gems, a catalog of older and overlooked games. Not quite it? Tell the Catbot what you feel like playing and it picks from the whole catalog, or browse by platform and genre.