Underplayed Gems

I Could Scare It Off (2026)

I Could Scare It Off cover

Developer: ElfoElfoDrofosfera
Platforms: Windows
Where to get it: itch.io

How it feels

A tense, quiet walk through eerily identical rooms while being stalked by an unseen presence that never quite leaves your sight.

atmosphericfirst-personshorttenseliminalquietuncanny

More games like this

Delivery Task (2026)
WE STAND AT THE DOOR (2026)
Without A Trace (2026)
Simulacrum (2026)
Ossa (2026)
Dreamcatch (2026)
Wonder (2026)
An Unreal Night (2026)

This page is from Underplayed Gems, a catalog of older and overlooked games. Not quite it? Tell the Catbot what you feel like playing and it picks from the whole catalog, or browse by platform and genre.