Underplayed Gems

Horror adventures you click your way through

No running, no aiming. You look at things, pick things up, and slowly work out what happened in this house. Horror suits the format, because a cursor gives you all the time in the world to dread the next room.

The 3D catalog: game boxes on wooden shelves, with the cat sitting at the counter next to its greeting.

The catalog in 3D

The same catalog has a room you can walk around in. The cat behind the counter is the AI Catbot, and they pick real games from it when you tell them what you feel like playing. Nothing is for sale, here or in there. They work from the whole catalog, not just this list.

Look around the 3D catalog

The Supper cover

The Supper (2020)

4.9 of 5 from 4,404 players · free · Windows

A short, atmospheric point-and-click adventure with dark humour and subtle psychological horror as you explore a kitchen and docks to serve a disturbing meal.

Players say: Players say this is a very short point-and-click adventure, about 20 minutes long, with simple puzzles and a story that builds to a touching reveal. The art style and music are praised, and it runs smoothly on the Steam Deck.

Purrfect Apawcalypse: Patches' Infurno cover

Purrfect Apawcalypse: Patches' Infurno (2021)

5.0 of 5 from 463 players · Windows, macOS, Linux

A cute and darkly comedic visual novel where you explore a school as a mischievous cat, causing cartoonish chaos with a playful, lighthearted tone despite the gore.

Don't Escape Trilogy cover

Don't Escape Trilogy (2019)

4.9 of 5 from 748 players

A tense, puzzle-filled point-and-click anthology where each bite-sized horror scenario demands careful thought to escape.

Players say: Players describe these as charming, bite-sized horror puzzle games with short playtimes and clever puzzles. They praise the retro pixel art and note the games can end badly if steps aren't planned carefully.

Growing My Grandpa! cover

Growing My Grandpa! (2022)

4.9 of 5 from 500 players · Windows

a bleak, atmospheric point-and-click adventure where a lonely girl raises a disturbing entity in a grim setting, with a slow, story-driven pace and a heavy sense of dread.

Players say: Players praise the thick atmosphere and unique story, likening it to an interactive SCP tale. Many find it unsettling without jumpscares, though a few call the gameplay repetitive and the experience short, with one reviewer saying monotony adds to the horror.

Cursed 3 cover

Cursed 3 (2022)

4.9 of 5 from 242 players · free

A moody, pixelated action-adventure that feels like navigating a dark, personal mystery through abandoned places and supernatural threats.

Players say: Players praise the combat, story, and replayability, with many calling it the best in the trilogy. Some struggle with a slider puzzle and a few bugs. The game is noted as nearly unplayable on Linux.

Scarlet Hollow cover

Scarlet Hollow (2021)

4.9 of 5 from 4,975 players · Windows, macOS, Linux

A slow-burn horror-mystery where every decision feels weighty, set in a sleepy town that grows increasingly unnerving through sharp writing and eerie hand-drawn art.

Players say: Players rave about the branching narrative, saying choices genuinely reshape the story across multiple playthroughs. They praise the cast and the blend of horror with a cozy tone, though some note it's still in early access with chapters unfinished.

Vincent: The Secret of Myers cover

Vincent: The Secret of Myers

4.9 of 5 from 1,767 players · Windows, macOS, Linux

A decaying corporate mansion hides gory sci-fi secrets you uncover through point-and-click puzzle solving and exploration.

Rodland of Pipes cover

Rodland of Pipes (2024)

4.9 of 5 from 279 players · Windows

Crawling through claustrophobic pipes, you carefully plan your route while unpredictable creatures stalk you, making every turn a tense gamble for survival.

Your Turn To Die -Death Game By Majority- cover

Your Turn To Die -Death Game By Majority- (2023)

4.9 of 5 from 4,259 players

A darkly atmospheric interactive story where every choice tightens the tension and shapes a grim, multi-ending survival drama.

Players say: Players praise its emotional character writing and branching choices, but the final chapter is still missing in early access. The puzzles and trials draw comparisons to Danganronpa and Zero Escape, though some find the logic frustrating or the sound effects annoying.

Lily's Well cover

Lily's Well (2022)

4.9 of 5 from 2,610 players · free

A rainy night home-alone adventure where you guide a girl to investigate a mysterious well with point-and-click exploration and multiple endings.

Players say: Players praise Lily's Well for its emotional storytelling and memorable true ending, but note the gameplay grows repetitive due to required item-collecting across cycles. A controversial lack of saves means starting over on death, which some find frustrating. The chiptune soundtrack and queercoded trauma themes are frequently mentioned.

The Walking Dead cover

The Walking Dead (2012)

4.9 of 5 from 79,955 players · Windows, macOS

A harrowing narrative journey driven by difficult moral choices and deep character bonds in a decaying, zombie-ravaged world.

Players say: Players say the relationship between Lee and Clementine drives an emotional, choice-driven story where timed decisions have no right answer. Several report technical issues like save file corruption and crashes, especially on modern systems. The ending draws consistent praise for its impact.

Nightmare Frames cover

Nightmare Frames (2022)

4.9 of 5 from 413 players · Windows

A moody, slow-burn point-and-click investigation through a sinister Hollywood and haunted town, driven by unsettling atmosphere and a dark mystery.

Players say: Players praise the story and pixel art, calling it a love letter to horror. Puzzles are simple and forgiving, making it accessible for newcomers, though there is no voice acting and some report a game-breaking bug.

The Deadseat cover

The Deadseat (2025)

4.9 of 5 from 624 players · Windows

A tense, atmospheric experience where you manage resources on a handheld game to defend against a supernatural threat creeping into your reality.

Players say: Players compare it favorably to Five Nights at Freddy's, praising the story and lore. However, many report frustrating input lag and a lack of controller or touchscreen support, with some calling the game janky on higher difficulties.

Sally Face - Episode One cover

Sally Face - Episode One (2016)

4.9 of 5 from 27,088 players · Windows, macOS, Linux

An unsettling point-and-click adventure where you explore a dark, hand-drawn world, solve puzzles, and uncover a sinister mystery with a melancholic, story-driven feel.

Players say: Players praise the deep, emotional story and genuinely human characters, often calling it a life-changing experience. Many played it years ago through let's plays and revisit it. Some find puzzles tricky without a guide, and one reviewer says the final episode feels rushed.

Garage: Bad Dream Adventure cover

Garage: Bad Dream Adventure (2022)

4.9 of 5 from 379 players · Windows

A slow, immersive crawl through a grotesque, decaying inner world where every rusty corner feels oppressive and lonely.

Cube Escape: Paradox cover

Cube Escape: Paradox (2018)

4.8 of 5 from 11,984 players · free · Windows, macOS

A tense and atmospheric puzzle escape game that feels like a surreal, mind-bending detective mystery.

Players say: Players praise the creative puzzles and unique short film integration. Some find the logic inconsistent, with a few puzzles feeling like trial-and-error. The game is short and free for chapter one, but chapter two is paid.

Inscryption cover

Inscryption (2021)

4.8 of 5 from 146,835 players

Playing Inscryption feels like being trapped in a dark, surreal game of cards where the line between game and reality keeps dissolving around you.

Players say: Players call Inscryption a genre-blending card game best experienced without spoilers. They praise Act 1's atmosphere and tight gameplay, but opinions split on Acts 2 and 3. Many appreciate the Kaycee's Mod for extra challenge. The game blends psychological horror with meta elements, comparing it to games like Outer Wilds and Dredge.

Slay the Princess — The Pristine Cut cover

Slay the Princess — The Pristine Cut (2023)

4.8 of 5 from 32,873 players · Windows, macOS, Linux

A tense, branching conversation with a sinister edge where every choice twists the story and the voice in your head questions your resolve.

Players say: Players rave about the voice acting and art, but opinions split on the story: many call it a profound love story that rewards blind playthroughs, while others find the philosophical themes pretentious and the looping structure repetitive after a few runs.

The Walking Dead: Season Two cover

The Walking Dead: Season Two (2013)

4.8 of 5 from 33,812 players · Windows, macOS

A harrowing, emotionally charged journey where every choice weighs heavy and survival depends on trust and tough decisions.

Players say: Players agree it is a worthy follow-up to the first season, though most say the story is not quite as strong. They praise the UI improvements and the way choices carry over from season 1. Many love seeing Kenny return, but find the new side characters hard to care about. The ending is consistently called heartbreaking.

Milk outside a bag of milk outside a bag of milk cover

Milk outside a bag of milk outside a bag of milk (2021)

4.8 of 5 from 22,022 players · Windows, macOS, Linux

A deeply introspective and surreal journey through anxiety and dread, told through fractured text and pixelated vignettes.

Players say: Players say this sequel improves on the first game with clearer art and animation, though some miss the original's oppressive atmosphere. The story explores mental illness from the inside, often feeling cryptic or uncomfortable, and getting all endings requires a guide.

This list is from Underplayed Gems, a catalog of older and overlooked games. You can also browse the whole catalog, or look around it in 3D and ask the Catbot there.