Underplayed Gems

RPG Maker horror games worth finding

RPG Maker gets written off as a beginner's toy, and then somebody uses it to make something that sits with you for a week. Top-down sprites, a lot of walking down corridors, and stories that go somewhere ugly. Plenty of these are free or close to it.

The 3D catalog: game boxes on wooden shelves, with the cat sitting at the counter next to its greeting.

The catalog in 3D

The same catalog has a room you can walk around in. The cat behind the counter is the AI Catbot, and they pick real games from it when you tell them what you feel like playing. Nothing is for sale, here or in there. They work from the whole catalog, not just this list.

Look around the 3D catalog

Look Outside cover

Look Outside (2025)

4.9 of 5 from 13,590 players · Windows

A tense survival horror RPG where you scavenge a derelict apartment building while avoiding the grotesque monsters that anyone who looks outside becomes.

Players say: Players praise the turn-based survival horror RPG's art, music, and story but split on its level design: four maze-like dungeons back to back frustrate some. Others highlight the 15-day time limit and deep consequences for choices.

Hello Charlotte EP3: Childhood's End cover

Hello Charlotte EP3: Childhood's End (2018)

4.9 of 5 from 3,359 players · Windows

A surreal, reflective descent into psychological horror that feels like a quiet yet deeply unsettling epilogue.

Players say: Players say the story is exceptional and the ending rivals the best in fiction, but some note the third episode splits the fanbase because it shifts the lore substantially from the earlier entries. Several reviewers report that the game changed how they think and feel, with one calling it 'brain chemistry altering'.

Tales of the Black Forest cover

Tales of the Black Forest (2019)

4.9 of 5 from 15,314 players

A dark, atmospheric pixel-art RPG where you solve puzzles and explore a mysterious town as a high school girl trapped by an unknown force.

Players say: Players praise the emotional depth and heartwarming ending, despite a slow start. The story deals with heavy themes like trauma, and the atmosphere blends slight horror with tenderness. Some find the jumpscares annoying, and the game is short, around 4–8 hours, with simple puzzles.

Mad Father cover

Mad Father (2016)

4.9 of 5 from 6,627 players · Windows

A tense, story-driven exploration through a gothic mansion filled with disturbing experiments and puzzles.

Players say: Players praise the sound design and straightforward puzzles in this short RPG maker horror. The remake adds visual polish and a choice between original and updated modes. Some find the story predictable and the true ending unsatisfying.

Trick & Treat Remake cover

Trick & Treat Remake (2021)

5.0 of 5 from 68 players · Windows, macOS, Linux

A quirky blend of cute doodle art and eerie old-school horror, with light puzzle-solving and a comedic tone.

Players say: Players praise the remake's updated visuals and keep the original's cute-and-creepy tone. A few note the loud footstep sound effect is annoying. Most finish in about 2 hours.

OMORI cover

OMORI (2020)

4.8 of 5 from 87,482 players · Windows, macOS

A deeply emotional journey that shifts between colorful, whimsical exploration and harrowing psychological tension.

Players say: Players call OMORI an emotionally powerful story about grief and trauma that builds slowly but rewards patience with a heartbreaking ending. The game is praised for its well-written characters and psychological horror, though some find the early pacing slow or controls awkward.

NARRENSCHIFF CH.1+2 (eng\chs) cover

NARRENSCHIFF CH.1+2 (eng\chs)

4.9 of 5 from 157 players · Windows

A quiet, story-focused pixel-art RPG Maker journey where light puzzle-solving unfolds amid a mildly unsettling atmosphere.

The Forest of Drizzling Rain cover

The Forest of Drizzling Rain (2022)

4.8 of 5 from 501 players

A tense, atmospheric exploration through a cursed village with pixel visuals and branching story paths that shift from mundane to fearful.

Players say: Players call it a faithful remake that expands the original freeware horror with more story and endings. A prison section puzzle remains untranslated from Japanese, so newcomers may need a guide.

NashBored cover

NashBored (2019)

4.9 of 5 from 83 players · Windows

A disorienting plunge into a dark, surreal dreamscape where fragmented memories and hostile entities blur the line between inner turmoil and a twisted game show.

Players say: Players love the story and atmosphere but warn it is emotionally devastating and very short. Some say to play DashBored first for full context. The game uses simple RPGMaker combat and dreamlike horror visuals.

Wooden Ocean cover

Wooden Ocean (2020)

4.9 of 5 from 244 players · Windows

A surreal and atmospheric RPGMaker adventure that blends dark fantasy and psychological horror with a strange, often funny tone.

Players say: Players describe Wooden Ocean as a deep RPG Maker game with a lot of content and frequent updates, though it can be hard at the start. The community also uses the word 'Murda' frequently, suggesting an inside joke or slogan.

Trick & Treat cover

Trick & Treat (2016)

4.8 of 5 from 2,408 players · free · Windows

A short, cute but eerie pixel-art adventure where you explore a haunted mansion as a witch's maid, mixing lighthearted character moments with unsettling puzzles and jump scares.

Players say: Players call it a short, wholesome RPG Maker puzzle game with simple puzzles and a cute story, taking about 2–3 hours. Graphics are dated, matching its 2016 release.

The Aquarium does not dance cover

The Aquarium does not dance (2024)

4.8 of 5 from 1,104 players · free · Windows

A gentle but eerie adventure through a surreal aquarium, where you solve puzzles and navigate mild scares while uncovering a story about friendship and loss.

Players say: Players enjoy this short pixel-art puzzle RPG for its creative puzzles and aquarium theme, though they note the story is simple and slow to develop with underdeveloped side characters.

Red Line cover

Red Line (2023)

4.9 of 5 from 185 players · Windows, macOS

A somber, story-rich journey where you switch between two struggling protagonists in parallel worlds, investigating clues and solving moderate puzzles to uncover a buried truth.

Players say: Players praise the story and the two-world premise, with a small but charming cast and a deep narrative. The horror is strongest in one early chapter focused on traditional Chinese family oppression, which several reviewers call genuinely disturbing, after that the game turns more heartwarming. Puzzles are moderately difficult and the length is short.

黑色花与红山羊 / Black Datura & Red Goat cover

黑色花与红山羊 / Black Datura & Red Goat (2020)

4.8 of 5 from 594 players · Windows

A tense, story-driven RPG where you explore eerie pixel-art environments, solve puzzles, and uncover forgotten memories through atmospheric horror and multiple choices.

Players say: Players praise the atmosphere and music but are divided on the story. Many call the bullying plot uncomfortable, and several note the bully gets no real punishment. The puzzles are light, with more text later. A common complaint is that some characters feel unnecessary and the true ending differs little from the good one.

LiEat cover

LiEat (2016)

4.8 of 5 from 4,658 players · Windows

a curious and optimistic girl who manifests lies as creatures travels a strange world with her dragon companion, blending a cute, story-driven journey with surreal and slightly eerie undertones.

Players say: Players describe LiEat as a short, cute RPG Maker game split into three stories, each lasting about two to three hours. The standout mechanic is the protagonist's adoptive daughter, a dragon who can eat and sense lies, which drives the plot. Some note that exploration can be unclear at times, and the story is modest but emotionally warm.

The Space-Eating Croc cover

The Space-Eating Croc (2023)

4.8 of 5 from 149 players · Windows

A slow, atmospheric mystery with pixel-art dread, where you explore a strange hotel by solving puzzles and uncovering a dark, supernatural secret.

Players say: Players describe a short, melancholic mystery adventure with light puzzles and a heavy focus on story and atmosphere. The English translation is noted as rough in spots, and opinions split on whether the surreal title fits the tone.

LISA: The Painful cover

LISA: The Painful (2014)

4.8 of 5 from 15,093 players · Windows, macOS, Linux

A relentlessly grim and darkly comedic post-apocalyptic RPG that forces you to make cruel, permanent sacrifices while pushing a pixelated 2D world of moral desolation.

Players say: Players praise the story and its ludo-narrative design, but are split on the gameplay, with some finding it tedious and the tonal shifts jarring. The game forces tough, permanent decisions and is unforgiving, yet its dark humor and soundtrack keep many coming back.

Misao - 2024 HD Remaster cover

Misao - 2024 HD Remaster (2017)

4.8 of 5 from 2,538 players · Windows

A tense, atmospheric horror-adventure where you explore a surreal school world, solving puzzles and unraveling a dark story.

Players say: Players call Misao a death gallery where everything kills you, which can feel like a rage game. Many find the story shallow and the characters one-note, while the remaster is noted as somewhat censored compared to the original. It's short, around 30-40 minutes if you know what to do.

羽翼的祈愿 - Feather Of Praying cover

羽翼的祈愿 - Feather Of Praying (2018)

4.8 of 5 from 326 players · Windows

A darkly emotional fairy tale blending unsettling puzzles with moments of warmth, where sadness and healing intertwine.

Players say: Players praise the horror atmosphere without jump scares and the well-balanced puzzles, while calling the story warm and the chase sequences difficult. Reviews split on the ending, some finding it imperfect.

Angels of Death cover

Angels of Death (2016)

4.8 of 5 from 5,338 players · Windows

A tense, story-driven journey through a dark building with a slow, eerie pace and a strange bond between two reluctant partners.

Players say: Players praise the story and the bond between Ray and Zack, calling it memorable and emotionally affecting. Some note the pixel art looks dated and the opening chase can be frustrating.

This list is from Underplayed Gems, a catalog of older and overlooked games. You can also browse the whole catalog, or look around it in 3D and ask the Catbot there.