Underplayed Gems
The whole movie catalogue

Films and series, searchable by what they are

← Back to the shop

Is It Cake? (2022)

Is It Cake? poster
Genre
reality television
Country
United States
Length
3 seasons, 24 episodes
Rated
TV-PG
Rating
6.9 of 10 from 60 voters
Elsewhere
IMDb

How it feels

Contestants make cakes that look like everyday objects and try to fool a panel of celebrity judges. The host, Mikey Day, guides the competition where bakers win money for their edible illusions.

playfulsillylightheartedsuspensefulwhimsicalcompetitiveentertaining

What happens

Is It Cake? is an American game show–style cooking competition television series created by Dan Cutforth and Jane Lipsitz, and hosted by Mikey Day. The series premiered on Netflix on March 18, 2022. Contestants create cakes that replicate common objects in an effort to trick celebrity judges. Winners of each episode receive $5,000 and a chance to win more money by identifying which display of cash is real and which is cake. The series is based on the viral internet challenge of the same name, popularized on YouTube and TikTok. The challenge involves showing a skillfully decorated cake disguised as a common object or food, and challenging viewers to determine if it is real or a cake replica. Day became fascinated by the challenge after his manager, Michael Goldman, introduced it to him. Although Day has no baking experience or background, he joined the show as host. Day explained the draw of the show is the "human desire... to pick out the 'disguised something'." In June 2022, Netflix renewed the series for a second season. The second season, titled Is It Cake, Too? was released on June 30, 2023. In January 2024, Netflix renewed the series for a third season, titled Is It Cak3? which was released on March 29, 2024. In October 2024, Netflix announced a holiday season special, titled Is It Cake? Holiday which was released on November 28, 2024. The special features nine all-star bakers from the first three seasons. Mikey Day reprises his role as the host. A second holiday special, titled Is It Cake? Halloween was released on October 8, 2025. A third special, Is It Cake? Valentines was released on February 4, 2026. (from Wikipedia, CC BY-SA)

Trailer

More like this

This page is from Underplayed Gems. Not quite it? Tell the Catbot what you feel like watching and it picks from the whole catalogue, or browse by genre, country and year.

Lists: Korean thrillers worth the evening · Anime films beyond Studio Ghibli · Slow films for a rainy night · Horror that unsettles instead of startling · Series you can finish in a weekend · Nordic crime worth the subtitles · Good films that end in under 90 minutes · Documentaries that play like thrillers

Loading movies…

What should I watch?