Underplayed Gems

Mystery Island:Missing Amy (2025)

Mystery Island:Missing Amy cover
Developer
TAPROMANCE
Platforms
Windows
Genres
Adventure, Indie
Rating
3.8 of 5, 12 player ratings
Typical playtime
about 1.7 hours
Where to get it
Steam

How it feels

A methodical point-and-click investigation with a dark, dramatic tone as you search for clues and solve puzzles.

point & clickmysteryinvestigationpuzzledarkdetectivestory-driven2d

What players say

Players say it is a short point-and-click game with easy puzzles, but the lack of in-game hints often leads to pixel hunting. The story is described as bland and formulaic, and the art has an AI-generated look that some find rough. Reviews split on the poor voice acting and mobile-game feel, with many finishing in under two hours.

Screenshots

Mystery Island:Missing Amy screenshot 1Mystery Island:Missing Amy screenshot 2Mystery Island:Missing Amy screenshot 3Mystery Island:Missing Amy screenshot 4Mystery Island:Missing Amy screenshot 5Mystery Island:Missing Amy screenshot 6

More games like this

More by Tapromance

This page is from Underplayed Gems, a catalog of older and overlooked games. Not quite it? Tell the Catbot what you feel like playing and it picks from the whole catalog, or browse by platform and genre.